It is officially called H.R. 1424, the
Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008. It is also called the
Wall Street Bailout Bill, the Rescue Bill, the largest Federal power
grab in US history, the socialization of the US Financial sector,
and, of course, the crap sandwich. As of a few moments ago, the
legislation passed the House on a 263-171 vote. Wall Street rallied
at the news while down on Main Street, folks are getting ready for a
piece of that sandwich.
The Core Proposals Have Not Changed,
Just the Wrapping
The heart of the bill, that lovely
great $700 billion Wall Street Bailout, is still there. This, of
course, means that one of the primary objections to the original bill
is still very much in place. True, the Senate version makes the
bailout more palatable—raising the FDIC insurance cap to $250,000
for example—but not in any way that really takes care of core
objections. What the Senate did was to tie a number of other popular
bills to the failed bailout proposal, add in a hefty helping of pork
and then drop it steaming and stinking onto the plate of the House,
figuring that there would be enough excess spending and tax-play to
make everyone happy. Oddly enough, they were right. Here are just
some of the things that the Senate included in this bill:
-
Rum producers in Puerto Rico and
the US Virgin Islands.
-
Wool research.
-
Corporations operating in American
Samoa.
-
Bicycle commuter benefits.
-
Children's wooden practice arrows.
-
Film and television productions.
-
Commercial fishermen affected by
the Exxon Valdez oil spill.
-
Motorsports complexes.
-
Mental health parity in health
insurance.
These are not all of the excess
provisions, which add up to an additional $110 billion over and above
the $700 billion already requested, but they are a vivid and, dare I
say, damning example of the culture that pervades Washington. Rather
than come clean, admit that the American people do not wish to give
this boon to Wall Street, and come up with something better—and
there were better ideas out there—our lawmakers stoically pressed
on with what originally failed, hoping to buy votes by including the
pet projects of stubborn lawmakers and much needed tax relief—such
as the annual AMT fix—in with the original bill that couldn't stand
on its own merits. It was a smooth piece of politicking, but it
stinks.
Would You Buy a Used Car From These
People?
No wonder no one trusts the government
anymore. When faced with a crisis of its own making, our government
resorts first to panic, and then to sanctimonious panic, then to
unctuous posturing guaranteed to make sure no one knows who's name
really ought to be associated with the crisis. Panic in this case was
the first, 3-page proposal from Secretary Paulson. Honestly, the only
way that could have been worse was if he had written it on the back
of a cocktail napkin. Sanctimonious panic followed in the subsequent
congressional negotiations and in the failed vote last Monday in the
House of Representatives. The Senate, meanwhile, moved on to
unctuous, pork-adding posturing, and managed to slide their fat
version of the bailout through and over to the House. Now we have the
spectacle of everyone engaged in ritualistic, post-bailout unctuous
posturing as those responsible do their best to keep that their
little secret while gravely intoning that something had to be
done.
The Bottom Line: Something Will Be
Done
Well, something was done. For
good or ill, right or wrong, The House today did somethingsomething that the Senate did a couple of days ago and
that the House tried to do at the beginning of the week, only this
time it was attached to a great many other somethings that
needed to be done. There is no telling what will happen. Stocks rose
on the news of the passage, but we need to see how this will play out
over time. Consider the words of Congressman Jeb Hensarling
(R-Texas), Chairman of the House Republican Study Committee, during
House consideration of the Financial Stabilization Package (emphasis
mine):
to
deal with the current economic crisis. It was, in great measure, the
same
Let me now speak to my hopes and
fears. No one truly knows if this plan will work. We all hope
it does. No one knows the true amount of taxpayer exposure. Treasury
could spend $700 billion in no time flat and come right back to
Congress for $700 billion more. Some believe the taxpayer will
actually make money in the deal and I hope that proves true. But
history as my guide, I have strong fears it will not. And at what
point do we finally bailout the American taxpayer from the
unconscionable burden he or she faces from out of control Washington
spending?
This bailout mess and the headlong rush
to do something to solve it tells us one thing: Perhaps the
biggest change we need in Washington is the elimination of unrelated
amendments and earmarks to legislation. Bills should be clean, of
single purpose, and given straight up or down roll call votes, no
more voting “present” to weasel out of taking a position. No
buying votes for weak, uncertain or even dangerous legislation such
as this bailout bill or the laws that Congress has passed over the
years that have brought us to this apparent point-of-no-return. I
know that isn't what the politicians would want, it would force them
to actually work for a living and be honest about their positions,
standing by their votes. I can't imagine many on either side of the
aisle wanting to do that, but what a change for the better it would
be!
Both sides in the presidential campaign
are offering change. This is a great test issue. Clean bills mean
transparency and accountability. They mean that bills would have to
stand on their own merits or perish, and that lawmakers would not be
able to obfuscate the issues as they do today. If that is a
suggestion for change that you would like to offer the campaigns,
visit www.johnmccain.com and
www.barackobama.com
and we'll see just how willing either side is to make a real change
to Washington culture.
In the meantime, pass the mustard.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to our free newsletter to receive future articles and information delivered directly to your email inbox.