Permit me to introduce you to Tom Golisano, founder and
board chairman of Paychex, Inc. His hard work through the years and a bit of
luck has made him a wealthy and successful man and one of the pillars of New
York society. He loves New York,
but he is pulling up stakes, leaving New York
and heading to Florida. Why?
Because the out-of-control spending, and the spate of new taxes and tax
increases imposed by Governor Patterson and the State legislature to pay for
it, have simply made it far too expensive for him to remain there. Golisano,
one of the wealthy job-creators whose taxes support the State of New
York, is withdrawing that support and voting with his
feet. In an open letter to the New York Post, he makes his feelings very clear:
I LOVE
New York
.
But how much should it cost to call
New York
home? Decades of out-of-control budgets, spending hikes and relentless
borrowing have made
New York
simply too expensive.
Politicians like to talk about incentives -- for
businesses to relocate, for example, or to get folks to buy local. After
reviewing the new budget, I have identified the most compelling incentive of
all: a major tax break immediately available to all New Yorkers. To be
eligible, you need do only one thing: move out of
New
York
State
.
Last week I spent 90 minutes doing a couple of simple
things -- registering to vote, changing my driver's license, filling out a
domicile certificate and signing a homestead certificate -- in Florida.
Combined with spending 184 days a year outside
New
York
, these simple procedures will save me
over $5 million in
New York
taxes annually.
By moving to
Florida
,
I can spend that $5 million on worthy causes, like better hospitals, improving
education or the
Clinton
Global Initiative. Or maybe I'll continue to invest it in fighting the status
quo in
Albany
. One
thing's certain: That money won't continue to fund
Albany
's
bloated bureaucracy, corrupt politicians and regular special-interest handouts.
How did the state get to this point? By spending,
spending and spending some more.
-
New
York
's budget was $72.7 billion in 1999.
Ten years later it ballooned to $131.8 billion. Each year, on average, the
budget has risen at an astounding 6 percent compounded annual rate -- more
than double inflation (2.8 percent).
-
Medicaid
spending alone works out to $2,283 for every man, woman and child in the
state. That's the highest in the nation and twice the national average. In
the last decade, the Medicaid budget grew 50 percent (from $30 billion in
1999 to $45 billion in 2009). In almost every sector (hospitals, nursing
homes, medicine, clinics and home and community care), spending per
recipient regularly exceeds the national average.
-
Faced
with escalating costs and diminishing returns, Albany and its allies --
that is, the health-care unions (SEIU Local 1199 has more than 300,000
members, many of whom are politically active) -- have only one answer:
increase taxes.
-
New
York spends the most, per pupil, in the nation on education. Our education
spending is 63 percent above the national average. Costs went up about 70
percent in the last decade (from $12.7 billion in 1999 to $21.8 billion in
2009).
-
Like
health care, education is something worth spending on and worth investing
in, but we're spending more and getting less.
New
York City
schools graduated only 54
percent of high-school students in 2007;
Buffalo
,
just 47 percent, and
Rochester
39 percent. Why do we keep spending more? Perhaps it's because
New
York
teachers unions spend millions
convincing
Albany
to spend more. And when faced with potential cuts, the union and its
allies had one response: increase taxes.
Nor is it just
Albany
.
After all, local governments tax, too. In
New York
,
the average total state and local tax burden is $5,260 for every man, woman and
child. That's by far the highest in the country. And like
Albany
,
when faced with problems, municipalities have one answer: increase taxes.
Upstate
New York
has been particularly hard hit. Add unreasonable real-estate taxes to
uncontrolled state spending, and you wind up with whole communities decimated.
An unworkable assessment process compounds the problem further. The result:
Fifteen of the 20 highest-taxed counties in
America
are right here in Upstate
New York
.
While homeowners in other areas build equity, we just pay more taxes.
This problem didn't begin with the current recession.
New
York
faced a $6 billion shortfall before the
economic downturn. However, in the face of economic turmoil, Gov. Paterson,
Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver and Senate Majority Leader Malcolm Smith looked
to the unions and special interests, who answered with one voice: raise
taxes.
That was irresponsible -- and may just prove to be
counterproductive, since the top 1 percent of earners account for about 50
percent of state revenue and are the ones who can and will leave. Among other
hikes in taxes and fees, they raised the marginal tax rate on the most
successful (and most mobile) New Yorkers to 8.97 percent, the second-highest
rate in the nation.
Bottom line? By domiciling in
Florida
,
which has no personal-income tax, I will save $13,800 every day. That's a
pretty strong incentive.
Like I said, I love
New York
.
But I'm not going to pay any more for the waste, corruption and inefficiency
that is
New York
state government.
It seems pretty straightforward: A person who creates jobs
and adds value is leaving the community because it is no longer economically
sensible for him to remain and the State is the poorer for it. This is
something that taxing politicians never seem to understand: the people with the
money will protect that money, even to the point of moving from high-tax
jurisdictions to low tax jurisdictions.
Also, unless a business is strictly local, so can business
owners. Given the electronic nature of our financial industry, it would not be
difficult at all for many businesses to pull up stakes and headquarter where
the grass is greener. Sometimes others will take the place of the departed,
sometimes not, but it has always been true that money votes with its feet.
People who are successful prefer to keep their earnings rather than subsidize
bloated government, whether that is on the local, state or federal level. On
the local level, it is no news that high-tax cities like Chicago
and New York City have seen people
and jobs drain away as the burden of government is increased. If Governor
Quinn’s 50% tax increase is passed in Illinois,
you will see people leave the state, especially entrepreneurs, the job
creators, who have the means to set-up elsewhere.
It is no surprise that out of control spending leads to out
of control taxation and the resulting exodus, but now we are facing that on a
national level. Will that mean that companies with the means will go offshore?
We are already seeing that in the energy sector. It takes little imagination to
see it coming in other sectors of the economy as well. After all, if all the
various governmental entities are taking as much as 50% or more from your
revenue, then why are you working so hard? Where is your incentive? That is
where Mr. Golisano was, questioning why he should remain in a place where so
much of his income was being taken by government.
His solution was to move, like so many others before him,
and so many others yet to go. That leaves those who remain to shoulder the
additional burden as more tax revenues will be needed to make-up the shortfall
of the lost taxes. It means more businesses close, which leads to more
unemployment, further shrinking the tax rolls but padding the rolls of people
on government aid and that leads up to a vicious spiral to ruin. We see it in Michigan,
and are seeing it begin in New York
and are likely to see it in Illinois
before the year is out. But it doesn’t need to be this way.
The Bottom Line
The government is too big—every level of government—and it is
sucking the life out of American business and American life. It was too big
under Clinton, far too big under
Bush and is growing at a rate usually associated with the monster in a Japanese
sci-fi flick. It is also doing things our founders never intended government to
do—things it has no business doing—and the cost of that bloated corpulance,
borne of a split between our government and the US Constitution, is disastrous.
It is not an issue of preferring Hamilton’s
Federalism to Jefferson’s Democratic Republicanism, but
rather John Madison’s middle path between the two, the path that keeps the
federal and state governments within their proper spheres and emphasizes the
prosperity of the American people over the power of government.
To do that, the people have to rein in their governments on
every level. America
can no longer afford ignorant voters; it can no longer afford a government that
acts beyond its rightful place. Politicians need to hear from you, from me,
from everyone that their number one job is to help you prosper, and that begins
with you keeping more of your hard-earned money. The wealthy already pay their
fair share, and my fair share and your fair share, too. How about everyone pays
their fair share? Instead of a tall, narrow tax structure that is balanced on
the checkbooks of people who can leave and take their money with them, spread
it out to all but the most destitute and make it low and fair for all.
New York
has
no business driving people out of the state for financial reasons, and only
because of a wide-spread yet horribly misguided ideology are they doing so. Our
founders foresaw the situations we are facing today that directly result from
that ideology, they saw them as clearly as if they had a crystal ball, and they
gave us a foundational document—the Constitution—written specifically to head
these problems off. It is time to reacquaint our government with its
foundation. If it’s been a while since you read it, visit the Constitution
of the United States and explore. You might be surprised by what you find.
Then contact your legislators and demand change—real
change—the kind you can believe in!
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to our free newsletter to receive future articles and information delivered directly to your email inbox.