Today, June 1st,
2009, is an historic date. It is the day that General Motors
entered bankruptcy. There are a lot of wide-eyes and crestfallen faces in Detroit
and Washington today, as if this
is some kind of surprise, a financial Pearl Harbor if
you will. It isn’t, this assault has been going on for a long time, and if you
want to know who sank GM’s battleships, you need look no further than the GM
corporate boardroom and the UAW. Because of weak leadership and
short-sightedness, GM executives have been systematically running the company
into the ground for years now and the unions have been right there adding
ballast and force to the effort, demanding more and more, sucking the
competitive life out of the company. Now, here we are. One of the parties to
the company’s demise—the unions—will now split ownership with the only entity
actually less competent to make sound financial and industrial decisions
for the good of the company, the federal government.
GM Bankruptcy and Small Business
That is the bleak landscape upon which a very large number
of small businesses will have to make a living, and many of these will have to
follow GM up the bankruptcy court steps, which will be a major blow, not only
to the auto industry but to the economy as a whole. According to Keith Gerard
at AllBusiness.com, Independent suppliers manufacture 70% of the 15,000 parts
that go into making a single automobile. Taken together, these companies comprise
a $388 billion industry within the overall automobile industry, accounting for over
600,000 (of the 2 million) American jobs tied to the auto industry. The
overwhelming majority of these suppliers are small businesses with an average
of 80 to 100 employees.
Will These Small Businesses Get Paid?
It is not just future work that is imperiled as the number
of nameplates—and the associated production—is trimmed down. With the
government holding such a large interest in the company, they will not let it
die completely. There will always be a level of productions, though how much
and of what is still in question.
The more immediate issue deals with payments on product that
has already been delivered. Many of these companies have been waiting for weeks
or even months to be paid and the bankruptcy protection is likely to stretch
that out even further. Those companies participating in the administration’s Supplier
Support Program—funded by the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP)—are seeing
payments withheld up to 180 days, which is resulting in severe cash-flow
problems for small suppliers. This has the effect of raising their risk
categories for lenders and receivables insurance brokers, which, in turn, leads
to even tighter credit terms, if credit is extended at all. Lenders and brokers
no longer see the auto industry, or those connected with it, as a good risk.
Of course, there is always the government’s 7(a) small
business emergency loan plan, right? The problem is that it doesn’t offer
enough to keep these firms afloat, and it requires personal collateral to the
tune of 20% of the loan and in this economy that is simply not realistic.
More than that, if the experience with Chrysler’s investors
is any guide to the way the government is likely to handle things, these small
businesses have little hope to recoup all of the money—or even most of the
money—that they are owed. Forced to take pennies on the dollar, and later
forced to renegotiate their prices to continue supplying the new GM and
Chrysler companies, you will see these firms struggling to survive and those
that cannot widen their customer base, or who cannot get ever-more-elusive
credit, will probably fail.
The Bottom Line
While an emergency loan may help bridge the gap for a time,
a look at the way the automaker crisis was handled by the government shows
rather graphically that it is no solution. After all, Obama threw billions of
dollars at the automakers to keep them out of bankruptcy, and it failed to save
them. It did, however, give him a chance to payback the unions, but that is a
different issue. The bailouts failed because they failed to address the labor,
product and management problems that had been plaguing Detroit
for ages. In other words, they failed because the problem was not money.
For these companies to have the best chance for survival,
they have to realize that their cash problems are not their real problem,
either. Rather, they are symptoms of a more fundamental problem—the market they
are in. Many of them will have to turn away from the auto industry and find
other markets to serve, other products to build, which will further exacerbate
the problems with the auto industry, but we are in an environment where “every
man for himself” is pretty good advice. These small businesses need to look to
themselves for salvation and with their skills and knowledge, they can do it. These
are good companies—too good to be trampled under the jackboots of a
government-run auto industry—and they should go forth to greener pastures.
Waiting for Washington to do
right by them could mean the end of them all.
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to our free newsletter to receive future articles and information delivered directly to your email inbox.